The BMW Club Technical Officer

From The June 2002 Journal (reprinted with the kind permission of Mike Fishwick)
Ultraseal Tyre Sealant – Can you afford to live without it?
by Mike Fishwick 
While punctures are now far rarer than they were, say thirty years ago, they remain one of the most common problems, which afflict the motoring public. Of course BMW claim that they only occur every 93,000 miles, this being used as justification for the absence of a spare wheel on their M Roadster etc. To give any odds at all on a random event is something, which no self-respecting bookie would ever dream of! My experience has been that punctures can occur at any time – ask anyone living on a new housing development where nails and screws etc abound. All that one can guarantee is that punctures will usually take place at highly inconvenient times. Of course, in the days before tubeless tyres became a universal fitment, and all motorcyclists were self-relient, it was easy enough to fit a spare inner tube by the roadside. This made a complete repair, and the damaged tube could be patched at leisure for future use. While many tubeless tyres can be fitted with tubes, (e.g. on Monolever Boxers), most modern machines use rim and tyre sizes which prevent such a repair being made. There is also the problem of safety while carrying out such a repair, for in many places – even lanes with high hedges – a stationary motorcycle and its rider may not been seen, particularly at dusk, until it’s too late.

Remember that most car drivers drive to the limit of what can currently be seen, and make no allowances for the unexpected.Temporary repair sealants, such as the various aerosol – packaged products are a quick way to become mobile again, but can only be used after coming to a stop. They are not suitable for prolonged use, and attach themselves tenaciously to the inside of the tyre casing. In most cases their composition is such that tyre specialists will refuse to repair a tyre, which has been internally coated with such a sealant.In the case of ultra-low profile tyres such as the ‘Z’ rated types found on many modern motorcycles a flat tyre could be a very expensive experience. The fitting of a vulcanised plug is not always possible if the puncture is close to the sidewall, and a limit of one repair per tyre is usually enforced. Even a gentle stop from speed can cause severe damage to the sidewalls, not to mention the wheel rims.Even without a puncture it is possible to experience rapid deflation, such almost happened to John Coleman during our return from the FIM Rally at Barcelona, when he ran over a rock while climbing towards the Col de I’Iseran in the French Alps. The front rim of his R80 deformed to such an extent that the edge of the tyre bead was visible over a length of about two inches. A fraction of an inch more and his front tyre would have deflated immediately, providing a rapid one-way trip to Bonneval – sur –Arc, about a thousand feet below!

The answer to all these problems would obviously be that of a puncture – resistant tyre, but in the absence of such wonders a good alternative is to coat the inside of the tyre with a tyre sealant which will always remain sufficiently fluid to fill the puncture as soon as it occurs. It goes without saying that it should not disturb wheel balance, and be capable of being easily removed if necessary.
Several such products have been marketed over the years, mainly directed at the motorcycle market. While tyre manufacturers do not recommend their use, no research has ever found sealants to have a detrimental effect. In every case of major damage to the front tyre, for example, the rider has maintained control and stopped safely.While most of them worked well, all had disadvantages. The usual problem was that after prolonged use at high speed the centrifugal force caused the sealant to separate and so lose its ability to seal for long periods. This was coupled with the extreme difficulty in removing the sealant in order to affect a permanent repair, so that a new tyre was the only effective remedy. Against this background Ultraseal appears to be the complete answer. It is not a new product, having been used in the United States for many years, and is approved by bodies as diverse as the U.S Postal Service, NASA and the American Armed Forces. It certainly seals well – I have personally attacked a motorcycle tyre with a spike until my arm grew tired, at the end of which pressure loss was negligible. After two weeks of such treatment by the public during a motorcycle show, the tyre had more puncture marks than tread, but still maintained it’s pressure.Ultraseal is claimed to be capable of repairing punctures made by objects up to 6 mm in diameter for the life of the tyre, and in the event of a larger area of damage it will provide protection from rapid deflation. It is water soluble in it’s uncured state, and I have seen it being easily washed out of a tyre casing to enable the fitting of a vulcanised plug.

Other properties include the ability to virtually eliminate pressure loss, even during long-term storage, and also to extend tyre life by up to about 30% due to improved heat transfer from the tread area to the wheel. Many riders find this increase to be in the order of 50%. This is probably why tyre manufacturers do not recommend its use!Wheel balance is not upset, and Asiatic Petroleum (Div of Shell Laboratories), and Dunlop GmbH have tested it at speeds of up to 150 mph, and a US government authorised tyre-testing laboratory to 40,000miles over a 2-year period, after which it remained liquid and still able to provide a permanent repair. All things considered Ultraseal appears to be the answer to a motorcyclist’s prayers, and many motorcycle dealers stock Ultraseal in D.I.Y. graduated dispenser bottles for home use.

A measured volume of Ultraseal – appropriate to the size of the tyre – is injected through the valve body, the small pressure loss being corrected afterwards. The initial quarter mile or so results in a strong imbalance effect which gradually reduces as centrifugal force spreads the sealant over the inside of the tyres in a uniform coating.
Although formulated for use in tubeless tyres, Ultraseal can also be used with inner tubes, as Cynthia Milton and John Adams demonstrated during their recent trip to Pakistan. John’s R100GS rear tyre was badly damaged by a two-inch long bolt, but retained pressure well enough to be fitted with an inner tube later. Cynthia was unaware of any problems, but when replacing her R80GS rear tyre after returning home she found the marks of 12 punctures which had been sealed without her even being aware of them! To cover 20,000 miles on one set of tyres through some of the worst roads in the Middle East and Asia without having to even remove the wheels is sufficient testimony for Ultraseal.

I have used it my car tyres for almost 20,000 miles, and can also confirm its claims. When one adds the cost of a simple puncture it can be a major problem. Assuming that one manages to stop without injury or damage, there is the nightmare of recovery, (often with additional delay because a motorcycle is involved), at horrendous cost if you are not a member of a suitable organisation. The recovery operation may itself cause damage to your motorcycle if it is badly secured to the ‘spectacle’ type frame designed to support the front wheels of a car, and may only take you to the nearest garage or service area.

It may then be found that the sidewalls and perhaps also the rims are damaged. Then there is the problem of finding a tyre specialist who will repair or change your tyre, not to mention the delay in obtaining a motorcycle tyre of the required size and type, particularly at the weekend. (One weekends in rural France one is simply resigned to waiting until Monday!) It may even be necessary to stay in a hotel for the night. Then comes the cost of the tyre itself, labour charges for changing it, and also to remove and replace the wheel, (Goldwing owners weep at the thought of this!) There is also the general hassles of being a motorcyclist in a system designed for car drivers. This can be expressed in terms of further damage to the rims, lack of dynamic balancing, and a general bodging by those who are unused to the more specialised and delicate requirements of a motorcycle.
A simple puncture could cost you a full day, and from two to several hundred pounds – can you afford not to use Ultraseal?
Mike Fishwick
Technical Officer 

Securicor Pony Express
Queen Street
Stourton
Leeds,
LS10 1SL
14/09/2002

Dear Sirs,
Ultra-Seal rules, hugely impressed, where, please can I get some more?  Have you any stockists in the West Yorkshire area?I was at the “Stormin’ the Castle” motorcycle rally in the wilds of County Durham, lovely country but miles from anywhere.  On Saturday morning there was a large MDF screw embedded in my back tyre.  By sheer luck one of the trade stands was selling Ultraseal.Now, I work as a motorcycle courier and have heard claims like these before, and learned to take them with a pinch of salt.  Still, I thought, it might just get me home.  I must admit I rode a bit gingerly, waiting for the bike to start slewing about as the back tyre lost pressure.  Of course, it didn’t.  And a thousand miles further on, it still hasn’t. >As for the other claims made for Ultra-Seal, yes it did make a difference to the handling of the machine.  A small increase in rebound damping adjustment was needed to take advantage. Best of all, it seems to be saving on fuel, too!  I have to keep accurate records – mileages, expenses for the tax–man – and can report a saving of 2 – 3%.  Which is enough over the life of the tyre to pay for the treatment. So, this stuff seems to do most of what it says on the box, and I’ve been singing its praises to all my workmates.  Each of us gets through at least half a dozen tyres per year.  And apart from any considerations of inconvenience or physical danger, we can’t afford the loss of earnings caused by such incidents as punctures.  Ultra-Seal seems to be the answer to the maiden’s prayer, if you could let us know where we can obtain it.
 

9/10/2002
Dear Alison,
Thanks for your letter.  Of course it’s okay to put mine on your website if you like.I shall be in touch with Adam shortly to re-order.  Punctures are a fact of life for motorcycle couriers – we get urgent calls during the afternoon rush hour, which means that we have to ride on bits of road, which larger vehicles don’t use, so all the debris accumulates there.  I’ve only used an emergency aerosol once, and it dissolved the adhesive from a previous repair, leaving me worse off than if I hadn’t bothered.  Ultra-Seal definitely doesn’t do that!I have, since I last wrote, discovered a limit to the size of hole which Ultra-Seal can fix, but it did slow the leak down enough to get me home in one piece.  And it was a BIG hole!